Project Hail Mary Review: Stunning IMAX Visuals, Shaky Science

Science vs. Sentiment: A Departure from ‘The Martian’

Project Hail Mary was not the film I was expecting. Based on the beloved novel by Andy Weir, this adaptation brings just as much outer-space jargon as The Martian (2015), but with far less plausible math or human capability. While Weir’s previous work felt grounded in rigorous “solve-the-problem” realism, this film drifts into the realm of speculative fantasy.

The stakes couldn’t be higher: Earth’s sun is being consumed by an unknown entity, triggering a global doomsday clock. When middle-school science teacher Ryland Grace (Ryan Gosling) awakens from a coma on a starship light-years from home, he must piece together his identity and save humanity. He isn’t exactly alone, though—an unexpected interstellar friendship becomes the heartbeat of the film, providing much of the humor and emotional weight.

Survival of the Funniest: Ryan Gosling’s Reluctant Hero

The casting of Ryan Gosling in a “save the world” mission seemed like an odd choice until the opening credits rolled. Unlike the hyper-competent Mark Watney, Ryland Grace is a reluctant spaceman who never asked for the job. Gosling is masterful here, balancing existential dread with an endearing, self-deprecating wit. The script is clever in how it uses familiar pop-culture references to ground his character, making him feel like a guy you’d actually know—rather than a calculated hero.

However, the “no space training” aspect is the hardest hurdle for the audience to clear. Grace isn’t an astronaut, yet he manages to solve complex astrophysical crises in weeks that would take NASA teams decades to decode. The filmmakers clearly expect us to stop overthinking the logistics and simply enjoy Gosling’s performance. For those of us craving a formula-driven narrative, the shift toward a “cutesy” and heartwarming tone feels like a missed opportunity for true tension.

An Interstellar Buddy Comedy?

What is so “cute” about a doomsday movie? This is the pivot point that will shock anyone who avoided the book or the trailers. Without spoiling too much, Grace meets a “friend” in the void, and their dual mission to save their respective species turns the film into a sci-fi comedy about problem-solving and cross-species bonding. It is exactly at this moment that all believable notions go flying out the airlock. If you can embrace the whimsical nature of this alien encounter, you’ll have a great time; if you wanted Interstellar, you might find it a bit silly.

Pacing Problems and the IMAX Spectacle

The biggest detractor is the length. At 2 hours and 36 minutes, Project Hail Mary is a massive time commitment. There are several repetitive sequences and prolonged shots of the vastness of space that could have easily been trimmed to keep the momentum high. Had the film clocked in under two hours, the final act might have landed with more emotional punch rather than being overshadowed by runtime fatigue.

Despite these frustrations, this is undeniably a film made for the biggest screen possible. Filmed specifically for IMAX, the shots of deep space are breathtaking and the sound design is absolutely engulfing. It’s rated PG-13, and while it’s safe for tweens, that nearly three-hour length might result in some serious fidgeting before the credits roll.

Pros: A genuinely charming alien companion, Gosling’s magnetic personality, and top-tier IMAX cinematography. Cons: Exhausting runtime, “magical” science, and a tonal shift that might be too sugary for hard-core sci-fi fans.

About The Author

Matt Mungle

Critics Choice Association Member. Subscribe to The Mungle Minute on my Insta page. It’s the minute that matters!

See author's posts